Part of First-Time Landlords: Getting Started guides
Rental Application: What to Ask, What You Can't, and How to Review It
What to put on your first rental application, the questions fair housing law rules out, what to know about fees and screening consent, and a step-by-step way to review applications and decide.
Short answer
A rental application should collect identity, contact details, rental history, income and employment, references, everyone who will live in the unit, pets, vehicles, and signed consent to run screening reports. Don't ask about race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability, which the federal Fair Housing Act protects, or about anything your state or city adds. Review every application against the same written criteria, and if a screening report affects your decision, send the applicant an adverse action notice.
Your rental application decides what you learn about an applicant, what you can verify, and what you can defend if someone later says you treated them unfairly. A good one is short, asks everyone the same things, and avoids questions you're not allowed to ask.
This guide walks a first-time landlord through building one, then reviewing applications and deciding in writing. If you haven't listed the unit yet, start with how to find tenants for your rental.
What a Rental Application Should Include
Every question should help you decide whether the applicant can pay the rent and follow the lease. If it doesn't, cut it.
- Identity: full legal name, other names used, date of birth, and whatever your screening company needs to run a report. Check a photo ID in person or by video.
- Contact: phone and email, so you can reach them and send a written decision.
- Rental history: current and previous addresses for the last two to three years, each landlord's name and phone, dates, monthly rent, and reason for moving.
- Income and employment: employer, position, start date, supervisor contact, and gross monthly income. Include a line for other income, such as benefits, support, self-employment or a housing voucher, so applicants who aren't paid by an employer can show what they have.
- References: one or two personal or professional references, mainly useful for applicants with thin rental history.
- Occupants: the name of every adult who will live there (each adult usually fills out their own application) and the total number of occupants.
- Pets: type, number, and size of any pets, so you can apply your pet policy.
- Vehicles: make, model and plate, if parking is limited or assigned.
- Consent and certification: a signed authorization to run credit, eviction and background reports and to contact landlords and employers, plus a statement that the information is true.
Questions You Can't Ask (Fair Housing)
The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits housing discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability (see HUD's Fair Housing Act overview). HUD's regulations say the ban on discriminatory statements covers written and oral statements, and they name applications specifically (24 CFR 100.75). The safe rule: don't ask about any protected characteristic, even casually at a showing.
Don't ask, and what to ask instead
- "Do you have kids?" or "Are you pregnant?" Familial status covers households with children under 18 and people who are pregnant (24 CFR 100.20). Instead ask: "How many people will live in the unit?" and the names of adult occupants.
- "Do you have a disability?" or "What medications do you take?" HUD's rules generally bar asking whether an applicant, or anyone associated with them, has a disability, or how severe it is (24 CFR 100.202(c)). The same rule lets you ask every applicant whether they can meet the tenancy requirements, and whether they currently use illegal drugs or have a conviction for making or selling them.
- "Where are you from?", "Which church do you go to?" or "Are you married?" National origin and religion are federally protected, and many states also protect marital status. You don't need any of these answers to decide whether someone can pay rent.
Your state and city probably add more
Many states and cities protect more groups than federal law, such as source of income, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, military status or immigration status. California is one example: its Department of Real Estate's California Tenants guide says landlords may not ask about immigration or citizenship status or discriminate based on source of income, and it describes limits on how criminal history can be used. Check your state's fair housing agency before you finalize the form.
One common misunderstanding: some small owner-occupied buildings are exempt from parts of the federal law, but HUD's rules say those exemptions don't apply to the ban on discriminatory advertising and statements (24 CFR 100.10). Your listing and your application still have to be clean. For the full picture, read our landlord's guide to fair housing laws.
Pets vs. assistance animals
Asking about pets is fine. But an animal a person with a disability needs is a different thing. HUD's reasonable accommodation rule uses a blind applicant with a guide dog in a no-pets building as its example of an accommodation a landlord must make (24 CFR 100.204). Note on your form that assistance animal requests are handled separately from the pet policy, and talk to a local attorney before denying one.
Application Fees: Allowed, Capped or Regulated, Depending on Your State
There's no single federal cap on rental application fees. Rules come from your state and sometimes your city, and they range from no specific limit to tight caps. Two examples from official state sources:
- California: the Department of Real Estate's California Tenants guide says the screening fee could not exceed $62.02 as of December 2023 and is adjusted each year for inflation. It also says the fee can't exceed your actual out-of-pocket costs plus a reasonable amount for your time, you must give an itemized receipt, you must return any unused part, and you can't charge a fee when you know or should know there's no vacancy.
- New York: state law limits background and credit check fees to the actual cost or $20, whichever is less. The landlord must give the applicant a copy of the check and the receipt, and must waive the fee if the applicant provides a check done within the past 30 days (N.Y. Real Property Law § 238-A).
Even where your state is silent, charge only what screening costs, give a receipt, and stop taking fees once a qualified applicant is likely to be approved. To keep costs down, see how to screen tenants on a budget.
Screening Consent and the FCRA
Credit, eviction and criminal background reports from a screening company are consumer reports under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The FTC's guide, Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know, says you can only get one if you have a permissible purpose, and that getting written permission from applicants helps show you do. Most screening companies require that signed consent anyway, so put it on the application.
When you must send an adverse action notice
According to the FTC guide, you owe the applicant an adverse action notice if you reject them, require a co-signer, raise the rent or deposit, or take any other unfavorable action based partly or entirely on a consumer report. It applies even when the report wasn't the main reason. The notice must include:
- The name, address and phone number of the company that supplied the report.
- A statement that the company didn't make the decision.
- The applicant's right to a free copy of the report if they ask within 60 days.
- The applicant's right to dispute inaccurate or incomplete information.
If you used a credit score, the FTC says the notice must also disclose the score and the key factors that hurt it. Oral notice is allowed, but the FTC calls written notice the best practice. The CFPB describes the same rights from the renter's side in what to do if a screening report gets you denied. Many screening services generate this notice for you; compare them in our best tenant screening services guide.
Handle Applicant Data Like It's Yours
An application holds enough personal data to steal an identity. The FTC's Disposal Rule guidance lists landlords among those who must take reasonable measures to dispose of consumer report information, such as shredding paper and destroying or erasing electronic files, and it applies to small operations too.
- Collect less. If your screening company collects ID numbers directly from the applicant, don't put them on your own form at all.
- Avoid email and text for documents. Use a secure upload, such as your screening service's portal.
- Lock it down. Paper in a locked drawer; files in an encrypted, password-protected folder only you can open.
- Keep only what you need. Keep your decision records; shred or delete the rest. Data breach and retention laws vary by state.
First-Come, First-Served and Written Criteria
Written criteria are your best protection against a fair housing complaint, because HUD's rules list using different qualification criteria or application procedures, including income standards, application fees and credit analysis, as prohibited when it's based on a protected characteristic (24 CFR 100.60). Write them down before you list, and share them with every applicant.
Typical criteria cover minimum income (many landlords use about three times the monthly rent; try the rent-to-income calculator), rental history, credit, and how you'll treat eviction and criminal records within your state's limits. Our step-by-step guide to setting up tenant screening criteria walks through each one.
Then decide how you'll order applications. A simple, defensible policy: timestamp each complete application, review them in that order, and approve the first that meets your criteria. Some places make this mandatory. California's DRE guide says landlords who charge a screening fee must screen completed applications in the order received and approve the first applicant who meets their criteria. Other places have their own rules, so check your state and city.
How to Review a Rental Application, Step by Step
- Check that it's complete. Every adult has applied, the consent is signed, and any fee is paid. Note when it became complete.
- Verify identity. Match the name and photo ID to the person you're dealing with, by video if not in person.
- Verify income. Ask for recent pay stubs, an offer letter, benefit letters or bank statements. Call the employer's main number, not the one on the application.
- Call previous landlords. Ask whether rent was paid on time, how the unit was left, and whether they'd rent to them again. A current landlord may be eager to see them go, so the previous one is often more candid.
- Run the screening report. Use the signed consent and a reputable service. Read the whole report, not just the score. If the applicant has little credit, see how to screen tenants without a credit check.
- Compare against your written criteria. If you allow compensating factors, such as a co-signer, apply them consistently and within your state's deposit limits.
- Write down the decision and why: date received, what you checked, which criteria were met or missed.
For the bigger picture of screening on a small portfolio, read our tenant screening guide for small landlords.
Red Flags on a Rental Application
- Blank fields in rental history, or gaps the applicant can't explain.
- A current "landlord" whose number goes to a cell phone that sounds like a friend, or who can't confirm basic facts like the address and rent.
- Pay stubs whose numbers don't add up, or an employer you can't verify through a public number.
- Names, dates or addresses that don't match the screening report.
- Pressure to skip steps: offering months of cash rent up front to move in today, or refusing to sign the screening consent.
- Adults who will live in the unit but won't apply.
A red flag is a reason to verify, not an automatic no. Ask about it and apply the same standard you'd use for anyone. Our guide to tenant screening red flags also covers what isn't a red flag.
Approving and Declining in Writing
Approving
Send a written approval with the rent, the deposit, the move-in date, and a deadline to sign the lease and pay. If approval comes with a condition based on the report, such as a co-signer or a larger deposit, that's an adverse action, so the FTC notice applies. Our guide to lease co-signers and guarantors explains how to set that up. Then sign the lease; if you're writing your own, start with how to write a lease agreement, and check your state's deposit limit with the security deposit calculator.
After the lease is signed, the next job is keeping track of who paid, and when.
Approved a tenant? Track the rent next.
Rentlane is an iPhone app for landlords with about 1–20 units. Your tenant keeps paying you directly. Link your bank or personal Venmo account through Plaid, and the app picks out incoming payments and matches them to tenants, leaving unclear ones for you to review. Rentlane doesn't screen tenants. Pro is $8.99/month through Apple.
Download for iPhone →Declining
Decline promptly, in writing, and keep it neutral. If any part of the decision came from a screening report, send the adverse action notice. Otherwise a short note is enough: "Thank you for applying. We've chosen another applicant whose application met our screening criteria first." Keep a copy with your notes. If your state requires refunding unused fees, do it now.
Sample Rental Application Fields
Use this checklist to build your form. Have a local attorney or landlord association review the final version, since some states require specific wording.
- Property: unit address, requested move-in date, requested lease term
- Applicant: full legal name, other names used, date of birth, phone, email
- Identification: photo ID type (checked in person), plus whatever your screening service needs to run a report
- Current residence: address, dates, monthly rent, landlord name and phone, reason for leaving
- Previous residences (2–3 years): the same details for each
- Employment: employer, position, start date, supervisor name and phone, gross monthly income
- Other income: source and monthly amount, with how it can be verified
- Occupants: names of all adults, total number of occupants
- Pets: type, number, size (assistance animal requests handled separately)
- Vehicles: make, model, plate
- References: one or two names, relationship, phone
- Emergency contact: name and phone
- Authorization: consent to credit, eviction and background checks and to contact landlords and employers
- Certification and signature: applicant confirms the information is true; date
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a landlord charge a rental application fee?
Usually, but it depends on your state and city. Some states cap the fee or tie it to your actual screening cost. For example, New York limits background and credit check fees to the actual cost or $20, whichever is less. Check your state's law before you charge anything.
Can I ask a rental applicant if they have kids?
No. Familial status, which covers households with children under 18 and people who are pregnant, is protected by the federal Fair Housing Act. You can ask how many people will live in the unit.
Can I ask for a Social Security number on a rental application?
Generally yes, and many screening companies use it to find the right reports. But some states limit this or require alternatives. California's Department of Real Estate says an applicant without one can provide other photo ID, such as a passport. If your screening service collects the number directly, leave it off your form.
Do I have to tell an applicant why I rejected them?
If the decision was based even partly on a screening report, the FCRA requires an adverse action notice naming the reporting company and explaining the applicant's rights. Otherwise federal law generally doesn't require a reason, though some states and cities may. Send a short written decision either way.
Do I have to rent to the first qualified applicant?
It depends on where your rental is. Federal fair housing law requires the same criteria and procedures for everyone but doesn't set a first-come rule. Some states do: California requires landlords who charge a screening fee to screen in the order received and approve the first qualified applicant.
How long should I keep rental applications?
There's no single rule; it varies by state. Many landlords keep applications and decision notes for a few years in case of a complaint. When you dispose of them, the FTC's Disposal Rule requires reasonable measures, such as shredding paper and erasing files.
Rentlane is not a tenant screening service. For reports, choose a screening company that follows the FCRA.
Disclaimer: Information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. Laws vary by state and locality. Consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Product pricing and features mentioned are accurate as of the publication date but may change.
Rent, leases and repairs in one iPhone app
Rentlane keeps rent records, lease signing links, maintenance requests and expenses together for small landlords. Tenants pay you directly, and Rentlane never touches the money.
Download for iPhone →