How to Find Tenants for Your Rental: Step by Step, From Listing to Keys

A plain walkthrough for first-time landlords: get the place ready, list it free, run showings, screen everyone the same way, and hand over keys with the paperwork done.

Updated November 10, 2026

Short answer

Write down your rent, rules and screening criteria first, then post a clear listing with good photos on free sites like Zillow Rental Manager, Apartments.com, Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, plus a yard sign. Show the unit, take written applications, and screen every applicant against the same criteria. Pick in writing, sign a lease, and collect move-in funds before you hand over the keys.

Finding a tenant for the first time feels like a lot of moving parts. It's really one process done in order: the 11 steps below take you from a unit that's ready to rent to a signed lease and keys in someone's hand.

If you're still deciding whether to rent at all, start with how to rent out your house for the first time and the first-time landlord checklist, then come back here.

Step 1: Get the unit rent-ready and set the price

A clean, working unit rents faster and attracts people who take care of things.

  1. Fix what's broken. Dripping faucets, sticky doors and burned-out bulbs read as "this landlord doesn't maintain."
  2. Check safety items. Smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, locks, handrails. Requirements vary by state and city, so check your local rules.
  3. Deep clean. Kitchen, bathrooms, floors, windows. Neutral paint touch-ups help photos too.
  4. Decide your terms. Monthly rent, deposit, lease length, move-in date, which utilities you cover, pets, smoking and parking.
  5. Price it from real comparables. Look at similar active listings near you: same bedrooms, similar condition and amenities. The rent calculator can help you sanity-check a number. Overpricing is the most common reason a good unit sits.

Step 2: Write your screening criteria before you advertise

This is the step most first-timers skip, and it protects you most. Decide what a qualified applicant looks like before anyone applies, so every applicant is measured against the same bar.

Typical criteria include:

Some states and cities limit what you can consider, such as criminal records, credit history or how a tenant pays rent, including housing vouchers. Check your state and local rules before you finalize anything. Our guide to setting up tenant screening criteria goes deeper, with examples.

Step 3: Take photos that do the work

Photos decide whether someone reads your listing at all. You need a clean unit, daylight and a phone held level, not a professional.

A short walkthrough video helps remote renters and cuts wasted showings.

Step 4: Write a listing that works

A good listing answers the questions people would otherwise message you about, which saves time and filters out people who won't qualify.

What to include

Describe the property, not the people

Fair housing rules apply to ads. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, a rental ad can't indicate "any preference, limitation, or discrimination" based on a protected class (HUD fair housing guidance). In practice, that means describing the home and its features rather than the tenant you picture.

Stuck on wording? Try the free rental listing description generator, then read how to create a rental listing that gets applications fast for more examples.

Step 5: Post it on free listing sites

You don't have to pay to reach renters. These four cover most of the market for a small landlord. Fees and features change, so check each site's current terms when you post.

Zillow Rental Manager

Zillow's landlord page says you can "post your rental listings for free" and offers an optional premium listing upgrade for a one-time fee (Zillow Rental Manager). It handles houses, condos, townhouses and room rentals, and it can also take applications.

Apartments.com

Apartments.com says "a basic listing on Apartments.com is free" and that the free package appears on six websites across its network. A paid Premium package adds more visibility, and its pricing varies by state and market (Apartments.com Rental Manager).

Facebook Marketplace

Marketplace reaches local renters who already browse it, and messages can pile up fast, so lean on your listing text and pre-screening questions to sort them. We couldn't load Facebook's help page on listing rentals when we checked, so check the site's current terms before you post.

Craigslist

Craigslist's fee page says "all craigslist postings are free," with listed exceptions. For housing, the exception is apartment rentals in the Boston, Chicago and NYC areas, which cost $5 (Craigslist posting fees). Craigslist is also a common place for copied scam listings, so see Step 9.

Checked November 10, 2026. Facebook's help page did not load for us.

Post the same text, photos and rent everywhere, and take every listing down the day you sign a lease. For more free channels, see how to market a rental property for free.

Step 6: Add a yard sign and spread the word

One rule: referrals go through the same application and the same criteria as everyone else. "My cousin's friend" is still an applicant.

Step 7: Answer inquiries and run showings

Pre-screen with the same questions every time

Before booking a showing, send every inquirer the same short message. For example:

Ask everyone the same questions, avoid questions about family, religion, origin, disability or other protected traits, and keep the messages as part of your record.

Showing options

Self-showing saves driving and lets people tour on their schedule. The tradeoffs: you aren't there to answer questions or see how people treat the place, you need a reliable way to verify identity, and the FTC warns that scammers sometimes copy listings from landlords who use self-tour services (FTC rental listing scams). If you go this route, read how to let tenants tour without you there first.

For in-person showings, tell someone where you'll be and show in daylight when you can.

Step 8: Take applications and screen everyone the same way

Use a written application, on paper or online, that every adult occupant fills out. It should ask for identity, current and past addresses, landlord contacts, employment and income, and consent to run any credit or background checks.

  1. Process complete applications in the order you receive them. Write down the date and time each one came in.
  2. Verify identity. Match the ID to the person and the application.
  3. Verify income. Pay stubs, an offer letter, bank statements or tax documents, compared against your written income rule.
  4. Call past landlords. Ask whether rent was on time, whether they'd rent to them again, and whether the deposit was returned in full.
  5. Run the checks you said you'd run. Credit, eviction and background reports through a screening service, with the applicant's consent.

Want to keep costs down? See how to screen tenants on a budget.

Fair housing applies to every step

The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits housing discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability (HUD: Fair Housing Act overview). That covers your ad, your showings, your questions, your criteria and your decision.

States and cities can add more. HUD notes that "some State and local governments have passed laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of source of income," such as housing vouchers (HUD: Source of Income Protections). Other places protect additional traits. Look up your state's civil rights or fair housing agency and your city's rules before you list. Our landlord's guide to fair housing laws covers the common situations, and this guide to emotional support animals covers a question many first-time landlords get.

The simplest protection is consistency: the same listing, the same questions, the same criteria and the same steps for everyone, written down.

Application fees: check your state first

Many landlords charge an application fee to cover screening costs. Whether you can, and how much, depends on where the rental is. Two examples:

Other states and some cities have their own limits, and some have none, so check before you charge anything. A good habit everywhere: only collect a fee from an applicant you're actually going to screen.

If you turn someone down because of a report

If you deny an applicant based on a tenant screening report, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires an adverse action notice. The CFPB says it must name the company that provided the report, with its address and phone number, and explain the applicant's right to a free copy within 60 days and to dispute inaccurate information (CFPB).

Step 9: Watch for red flags and scams

Applicant red flags

One red flag isn't automatically a no: apply your written criteria and document what you found. Our tenant screening red flags guide covers what to look for beyond credit scores.

Scams that use your listing

Scammers copy real listings, swap in their own contact details and repost them, then collect "deposits" from renters who never reach the real owner (FTC). To protect your renters and your reputation:

Step 10: Choose a tenant and record why, in writing

When more than one applicant qualifies, use a method you can explain and repeat. Two common approaches:

Some cities regulate the order in which you consider applications, so check local law. Either way:

  1. Write a short decision note for each applicant: date received, what you verified, and approved or declined with the criterion it was based on.
  2. Send the approval in writing with a deadline to sign the lease and pay move-in funds.
  3. Send declines in writing, plus the adverse action notice if a screening report was part of the reason.
  4. Keep applications, notes and messages. Ask a local attorney how long to keep them in your state.

Step 11: Sign the lease, collect move-in funds and hand over keys

The lease

Use a lease written for your state, and include your state's required disclosures. Those depend on where the property is and, in some cases, its age. See the lead paint disclosure guide if your home is older. Our guide on how to write a lease agreement covers the clauses to include. Having a local attorney review your first lease is money well spent.

Walk the tenant through the key terms (rent, due date, how to pay, late fees, maintenance requests) and then sign. E-signing works well when everyone is on their phone.

Move-in funds

Collect the security deposit and first month's rent before you hand over keys, and wait until the payment has actually cleared. Deposit limits, where you hold the money and return deadlines all vary by state. The security deposit calculator is a starting point, but confirm your state's rules.

Decide now how rent will be paid going forward, such as Zelle, Venmo, bank transfer or check, and put it in the lease.

Lease signed. Now keep rent organized.

Rentlane sends DocuSeal signing links for your lease, then keeps rent records in one place on your iPhone. Tenants keep paying you directly by Zelle, Venmo, bank transfer or check, and Rentlane does not move or process rent.

After you link your bank or personal Venmo account through Plaid, Rentlane picks out Zelle and Venmo payments and matches them to tenants. Anything unclear is left for you to review, and checks and cash are entered by hand. Rentlane Pro is $8.99/month through Apple.

Download for iPhone →

Move-in day

  1. Do a move-in inspection together. Photos and notes for every room, signed by both of you. Use the move-in checklist template.
  2. Hand over keys and note how many of each you gave.
  3. Share the basics: how to reach you, how to report maintenance, utility setup and trash days.
  4. Take down every listing and the yard sign.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I list my rental for free?

Zillow Rental Manager and Apartments.com both say a basic listing is free, with optional paid upgrades. Craigslist is free for housing except apartment rentals in the Boston, Chicago and NYC areas, which cost $5. Facebook Marketplace is widely used for rentals; check its current terms. A yard sign and word of mouth cost little or nothing.

How do I find good tenants for my house?

Write your screening criteria before you advertise, post a detailed listing so unqualified renters self-select, and verify identity, income and rental history for every applicant. Record why you approved or declined each person.

Can I charge a rental application fee?

In many places, yes, but limits vary. New York caps credit and background check fees at $20 before a lease is signed, and California limits the fee to actual costs under an inflation-adjusted cap. Check your state and city rules before charging.

Do I have to rent to the first qualified applicant?

It depends on where the rental is. Some cities have rules about the order in which applications must be considered. Even where you can choose, a consistent written method, like first complete qualified application or a comparison on your written criteria, helps you treat everyone fairly.

What can't I ask a rental applicant?

Don't ask about or decide based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability, which the federal Fair Housing Act protects. Many states and cities protect more, such as source of income. Stick to questions tied to your written criteria.

How do I avoid rental scams when I list my property?

Search your address and photos for copied listings, say in your ad that you never ask for money before a showing, and report copies to the site. Be wary of applicants who overpay and ask for a refund.

Disclaimer: Information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. Laws vary by state and locality. Consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Product pricing and features mentioned are accurate as of the publication date but may change.

Rent records for your first rental

Rentlane is an iPhone app for landlords with about 1 to 20 units: lease signing links, rent records, push rent reminders for tenants who join their lease in the app, maintenance requests with photos, and expense records with a Schedule E CSV export. Tenants pay landlords directly; Rentlane does not move or process rent.

Download for iPhone →

Practical answers for collecting rent, signing leases, screening tenants, and running a rental with confidence.

Browse all landlord guides

Rentlane Track rent on iPhone

Get the app