Part of First-Time Landlords: Getting Started guides
Should I Rent or Sell My House? A Simple Way to Decide
Run your monthly numbers in two minutes, then check the seven things a calculator can't see.
Short answer
Rent it out if the rent covers your mortgage, taxes, insurance and a realistic cushion for repairs and empty months, you have savings to fall back on, and you have a reason to keep the house. Sell if the numbers are thin or negative, you'd be managing from far away with no help, or a large tax-free gain is at stake and the IRS's 2-out-of-5-years window would close before you'd sell. Use the calculator below, then work through the decision checklist.
You're moving. Maybe it's a new job, a bigger place or a partner's city. Now you're staring at the house you still own and asking the question everyone asks: do I sell it, or do I keep it and rent it out?
There's no single right answer. A house that makes a great rental for one person is a stressful money pit for another. The good news is that the decision comes down to two things you can check: the monthly cash flow and a short list of personal and legal factors. This guide walks you through both.
Step 1: Run the Monthly Numbers
Start with cash flow: what's left each month after the rent comes in and the bills go out. The math is simple:
Cash flow = rent − mortgage (principal + interest) − property tax − insurance − HOA − reserves for maintenance, vacancy and management
The reserves are a percentage of rent that you set aside, because repairs and empty months will happen even if they don't happen every month.
Rent vs. sell cash flow calculator
Enter monthly amounts. The three percentages start at 8% maintenance, 5% vacancy and 0% management. Those are editable starting assumptions, not facts. Older homes, high-turnover areas or a hired manager can push them higher, so change them to fit your house.
A worked example (made-up numbers)
Say similar homes rent for $2,400. Your principal and interest is $1,500, property tax is $350 a month, a landlord policy is $150 a month and there's no HOA. With the starting assumptions, maintenance is 8% of rent ($192) and vacancy is 5% ($120).
- Total monthly costs: $1,500 + $350 + $150 + $192 + $120 = $2,312
- Monthly cash flow: $2,400 − $2,312 = $88
- Yearly cash flow: $1,056
Now hire a manager at 8% of rent ($192). The same house goes to −$104 a month, or −$1,248 a year. That's how thin the margin can be, and why the management line matters. Our break-even analysis of self-managing vs. hiring a property manager helps you decide which number to use.
How to read your result
- Clearly positive with realistic assumptions: renting can pay for itself. Keep going to Step 2.
- Close to zero: one big repair or a few empty months turns it negative. You'd be keeping the house for equity or a future move back, not income. That can still be a fine reason, as long as you know it.
- Negative: you'd be paying each month to keep the house. Only do that on purpose, with a clear plan and the savings to cover it.
Not sure what rent to enter? Our guide to calculating rent for your property shows how to price from comparable listings. For a fuller picture of return on the equity you'd leave in the house, try the free rental property ROI calculator. And once you have a tenant lined up, the rent calculator checks rent-to-income ratios and late fees.
What the calculator leaves out
Cash flow is a starting point, not a verdict. Before you decide, think about:
- Equity and appreciation. Part of each mortgage payment pays down the loan, and the home may rise (or fall) in value. Neither shows up as monthly cash.
- Big-ticket items. A roof, a water heater or an HVAC system can cost more than a year of cash flow. The maintenance reserve is meant to soften these, not cover all of them.
- Turnover costs. Cleaning, paint, listing time and an empty month between tenants.
- Taxes. Rent is taxable income, but you can usually deduct expenses like mortgage interest, property tax, insurance and repairs, and depreciate the building. See IRS Publication 527 and our plain-English guide to rental depreciation.
- The cost of selling later. Agent commissions and closing costs don't go away if you rent first. You'll pay them whenever you eventually sell.
Step 2: Weigh the Factors a Calculator Can't See
Two people with the exact same numbers can make opposite (and correct) choices. These are the questions that usually decide it.
1. Will you move back?
If there's a real chance you'll return in a few years, for a temporary job assignment, a military posting or family reasons, renting lets you keep the house without buying again later. If you're sure you're gone for good, the "keep it in case" reason disappears, and the house has to earn its place as an investment.
2. How far away will you be?
Across town, you can meet a plumber, show the house and do a move-out inspection yourself. Across the country, you'll need a local handyman you trust, a way to show the home, and probably a property manager, which changes your numbers. Our guide to managing a rental property remotely covers what long-distance landlording really takes.
3. How do you feel about tenant calls?
Self-managing means you're the one who hears about the leaking toilet, the broken dishwasher and the late rent. Some people don't mind. Others find it draining on top of a new job and a move. Be honest with yourself here. If the answer is "I'd hate it," either budget for a manager in the calculator or lean toward selling.
4. Do you have an emergency fund for the house?
A rental needs its own cash cushion, separate from your personal savings, for repairs, empty months and the occasional tenant who pays late. If one surprise bill would land on a credit card, renting is riskier than the cash flow suggests. Our step-by-step landlord emergency fund guide shows how to size one.
5. The home-sale tax exclusion and its 2-out-of-5-years test
This one can be worth a lot, so it's worth understanding. Under the federal rules in IRS Publication 523, if you sell your main home you may be able to exclude up to $250,000 of gain from income ($500,000 for most married couples filing jointly). To qualify, you generally must have owned the home and lived in it as your main home for at least 2 years (24 months) out of the 5 years before the sale. The two years of living there don't have to be in one block.
Here's why it matters for this decision: once you move out and rent the house, the 5-year window keeps moving. If you lived there for two full years right before moving out, you generally have about three years to sell and still meet the test. Rent it longer than that, and you may lose the exclusion on a sale.
Two more things to know from Publication 523:
- Depreciation isn't covered. The part of your gain equal to depreciation on the home after May 6, 1997 can't be excluded and is generally taxed when you sell.
- Time after you move out is treated differently. Rental time that falls in the 5-year period after the last date you lived there generally doesn't reduce your exclusion under the "nonqualified use" rules, as long as you still meet the 2-out-of-5 test. Time rented before you moved in can count against it.
There are special rules for military and some other government service, partial exclusions for moves due to a job change or health, and limits if you used the exclusion on another home in the last two years. If your gain is large, talk to a CPA before you sign a lease. Their advice could change the answer.
6. Your mortgage's occupancy rules (talk to your lender)
If you bought the home as your primary residence, your mortgage may say how long you have to live there. For example, the standard Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac security instrument (see this sample deed of trust published by the CFPB) asks the borrower to move in within 60 days and live there as a principal residence for at least one year, unless the lender agrees in writing or circumstances beyond the borrower's control apply. FHA, VA and other loans have their own occupancy rules.
If you've lived there past any required period and are moving for real reasons, renting may well be fine. But don't guess. Read your mortgage documents and call your lender or servicer before you list the house for rent.
7. Switching your insurance
A homeowners policy is written for a home you live in. Once a tenant moves in, you'll usually need a landlord (dwelling) policy instead, and your tenant should get renters insurance for their belongings. Call your insurer before the lease starts so there's no gap, and use the real quote in the calculator. Our guide to rental property insurance vs. homeowners insurance explains what changes.
A Simple Way to Decide
Put your calculator result next to the factors above. If most of your answers land in one column, that's your answer.
Lean toward renting if:
- Cash flow is positive with realistic reserves (and a manager, if you'll need one).
- You might move back, or you want to hold the house long-term.
- You're close enough to manage it, or the numbers still work with a manager.
- You have a separate emergency fund for the house.
- Your lender allows it, and you've lined up landlord insurance.
Lean toward selling if:
- Cash flow is negative or near zero and you don't have a strong reason to keep the house.
- You'll be far away and don't want to pay for (or deal with) management.
- You need the equity for your next home or to rebuild savings.
- You have a large gain and renting would push you past the 2-out-of-5-years window.
- The thought of tenant calls and repairs fills you with dread.
Still split? Some owners rent with a one-year lease and decide again before it ends. Just keep an eye on the tax clock while you do.
If You Decide to Sell
Selling is the simpler path. Before you list:
- Check your tax position. Confirm you meet the ownership and use test in Publication 523, and keep records of what you paid and what you spent on improvements. They raise your basis and lower any taxable gain.
- Get a few agent opinions on price and on which repairs are worth doing before listing.
- Time the sale with your move so you're not paying for two homes longer than you have to.
If You Decide to Rent
Becoming a landlord by accident is common, and it's very doable with a plan. Our accidental landlord guide covers the whole picture, and our step-by-step guide on how to rent out your house walks through getting it listed. Here's the short version:
- Call your lender and confirm renting is allowed under your mortgage.
- Switch to a landlord insurance policy that starts the day the lease does.
- Learn your state and local landlord-tenant rules. Security deposit limits, required disclosures, notice periods and rental registration vary by state and city.
- Get the house rent-ready. Our guide to converting your home into a rental property covers repairs, safety items and what to leave behind.
- Set the rent from real comparables, not what you'd like to get.
- Screen tenants the same way every time. Follow our tenant screening guide for small landlords and stay within fair housing law.
- Use a written, state-specific lease. See how to write a lease agreement.
- Set up rent tracking and records from day one. Keep rent and expenses separate from your personal money so tax time is simple. Rental income and expenses are generally reported on Schedule E; our Schedule E guide for landlords explains how.
Renting it out? See who paid without changing how tenants pay
Rentlane is an iPhone app for landlords with about 1–20 units. Your tenants keep paying you directly by Zelle, Venmo, bank transfer or check. Link your bank through Plaid and Rentlane matches Zelle and Venmo payments to your tenants, leaves unclear ones for you to review, and keeps expense records with a Schedule E CSV export. It never moves or holds rent.
Download for iPhone →Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to rent out or sell my house?
It depends on your numbers and your situation. Renting tends to make sense when the rent covers all costs plus reserves for repairs and vacancy, you have an emergency fund, and you want to keep the house. Selling tends to make sense when cash flow is thin or negative, you'd be managing from far away, or renting would cost you the home-sale tax exclusion on a large gain.
Should I rent or sell my house when moving?
Start with how likely you are to move back and how far away you'll be. If you may return and the house at least covers its costs, renting keeps your options open. If you're leaving for good, the house is far away and the numbers are tight, selling is usually simpler.
Do I need to tell my mortgage lender I'm renting my house?
Check with your lender before you rent. Many primary-residence mortgages require you to live in the home for a set period, often at least one year on standard Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans, and FHA and VA loans have their own rules. Read your mortgage documents and call your lender or servicer to confirm renting is allowed.
Will I pay capital gains tax if I rent my house before selling it?
Possibly. Under IRS Publication 523, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for most married couples filing jointly) if you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. Rent it too long and you can lose that exclusion, and depreciation taken after May 6, 1997 can't be excluded. Ask a CPA about your situation.
Do I need different insurance if I rent out my house?
Usually yes. A homeowners policy is written for a home you live in, so most owners switch to a landlord (dwelling) policy when a tenant moves in. Call your insurer before the lease starts and ask your tenant to carry renters insurance.
How do I calculate if renting my house is worth it?
Subtract your monthly mortgage principal and interest, property tax, insurance and HOA from the expected rent, then subtract reserves for maintenance, vacancy and any property management, each as a percentage of rent. Multiply by 12 for yearly cash flow. Then weigh what cash flow leaves out: equity, appreciation and taxes.
Disclaimer: Information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. Laws vary by state and locality. Consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Product pricing and features mentioned are accurate as of the publication date but may change.