# How Much Is Landlord Insurance? Costs and What Changes the Price (2026)

Source: https://getrentlane.com/blog/how-much-is-landlord-insurance
Updated: 2026-11-10

What a landlord policy covers, why it usually costs more than homeowners insurance on the same house, and how to get a real number for yours.

> Short answer
>
> Landlord insurance is a policy for a home you rent to someone else, usually written on a dwelling form (DP-1, DP-2 or DP-3, with DP-3 the broadest). The [Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I)](https://www.iii.org/article/coverage-for-renting-out-your-home) says landlord policies generally cost about 25% more than a standard homeowners policy on the same property.
>
> What you'll actually pay depends mostly on where the house is, its age, condition and rebuild cost, the policy form and limits, your deductible, your claims history, and whether you rent long-term, short-term or leave it empty for stretches. The only reliable number is a quote for your house.

If you're about to rent out a house for the first time, maybe the one you just moved out of, insurance is one of the first bills that changes. Your old policy was priced for a home you live in. Once a tenant moves in, the insurer is covering a different risk.

This guide is about the cost: what drives the premium, how to compare quotes fairly, and how to bring the price down without stripping out coverage you'll want later. If you want the full rundown of which coverages to buy, read [landlord insurance: what you actually need](https://getrentlane.com/blog/landlord-insurance-what-you-actually-need) alongside this one.

## Why there's no honest "average" price

You'll see national averages quoted all over the internet. We're not adding another one. Premiums vary by state, ZIP code, insurer and the house itself, so a national figure tells you very little about your own bill.

The one benchmark worth knowing comes from Triple-I: landlord policies [generally cost about 25% more](https://www.iii.org/article/coverage-for-renting-out-your-home) than a standard homeowners policy on the same property, to pay for the extra protections they include. Use that as a rough sense of direction, not a forecast.

Two things can push your real number away from that 25%:

- **You may be insuring less of your own stuff.** A homeowners policy covers your furniture and belongings. Once you move out, a landlord policy usually covers only what you leave behind for the tenant, such as appliances. That can change the comparison.
- **You may be buying more of other things.** Loss-of-rent coverage, higher liability limits and add-ons like water backup all add to the premium.

So compare quotes like for like: the same rebuild amount, the same liability limit, the same deductible.

## What landlord insurance covers vs. homeowners insurance

A homeowners policy typically covers the structure, your belongings, your personal liability and your living costs if you're displaced. A landlord policy treats the building as a business asset. Our [rental property insurance vs. homeowners comparison](https://getrentlane.com/blog/rental-property-insurance-vs-homeowners) covers the differences in detail; here's the short version, with what each piece does to the price.

### The three dwelling forms

According to the [North Carolina Department of Insurance](https://www.ncdoi.gov/consumers/homeowners-insurance/dwelling-policies), dwelling policies come in three standard forms:

- **DP-1 (basic):** covers only the perils it names, typically fire, lightning and internal explosion, with others such as windstorm or hail added for extra premium. Usually the cheapest form, and the thinnest.
- **DP-2 (broad):** still a named-perils policy, but adds more, such as vandalism, windstorm or hail and burglary damage.
- **DP-3 (special):** an "open perils" policy for the dwelling and other structures, meaning it covers causes of loss unless they're excluded. Personal property under DP-3 is still covered on a named-perils basis.

Broader forms generally cost more because they pay for more kinds of losses. Ask for quotes on DP-3 and at least one narrower form so you can see the actual price difference for your house.

### Loss of rents

If a covered loss, like a fire, makes the house unlivable, loss-of-rents (sometimes called fair rental value) coverage replaces the rent you would have collected while it's repaired. Triple-I notes that most landlord policies include it, generally for a set period. It's one reason a landlord policy costs more, and it's usually worth having: a long repair with no rent coming in can wipe out a year of profit.

### Liability

Liability coverage pays for legal defense and damages if someone is hurt on the property and blames you. Here's the catch: Triple-I describes landlord policies as including liability, but the North Carolina guide says dwelling policies *typically don't* include it the way homeowners forms do. What you get depends on the insurer and the form. Check the declarations page. If liability isn't listed, ask how to add it, and include it in every quote you compare. A cheap quote without liability isn't cheap.

### What isn't covered

- **Your tenant's belongings.** Triple-I is clear that a tenant's possessions aren't covered under your policy. That's what renters insurance is for (more below).
- **Flood and earthquake** are usually excluded and bought separately, which can add a lot to your total cost in high-risk areas.
- **Wear and tear and slow problems** like a leak that's been dripping for months. Our [guide to handling landlord insurance claims](https://getrentlane.com/blog/handling-insurance-claims-landlord-guide) covers what tends to get paid and what doesn't.

## What changes the price of landlord insurance

The [National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC)](https://content.naic.org/article/consumer-insight-searching-homeowners-insurance-policy-tips-get-most-value) lists the factors insurers use to price home coverage: the cost to rebuild, construction type, distance to a fire department or water source, the home's age and condition, its claims history, your coverage and deductible, your claims history, insurance-based credit history, and features like a pool or trampoline. Rental policies add a few factors of their own. Here's how each one tends to play out.

### 1. Location

Usually the biggest driver. Weather and disaster risk, local building costs and distance to a fire station all feed into the rate, which is why premiums can rise even when nothing about your house changed.

### 2. Rebuild cost, age and condition

Insurers price the cost to rebuild, not the market value or what you paid. Bigger houses and costlier materials cost more to insure, and older roofs, wiring and plumbing raise the odds of a claim.

### 3. Policy form and coverage limits

DP-3 usually costs more than DP-1. Higher limits, a longer loss-of-rents period and add-ons all raise the premium.

### 4. Deductible

The NAIC notes that a higher deductible may lower your premium, as long as you can afford to pay it after a loss. Ask each insurer to quote two or three deductible levels so you can see the trade-off in dollars.

### 5. Claims history

Past claims on the house, and on you, can raise the price or limit which insurers will quote.

### 6. Credit-based insurance score

Many insurers use insurance-based credit history in pricing, though some states limit or restrict how it can be used. Check with your state insurance department if you're unsure what applies to you.

### 7. Long-term vs. short-term rental

Renting nightly or weekly is priced differently from a year-long lease. Triple-I's [March 2026 report on short-term rentals](https://www.iii.org/sites/default/files/docs/pdf/short-term_rentals_and_homeowners_insurance_outlook_03092026.pdf) says regular homeowners insurance typically doesn't cover losses from commercial activity, that owners planning short-term rentals need to buy additional coverage, and that short-term renting typically leads to higher premiums. If you plan to switch between short-term and long-term renting, tell your insurer about both.

### 8. Vacancy

An empty house is a bigger risk. Many dwelling policies limit coverage after a property has been vacant for a set period. North Carolina's description of DP-2, for example, covers accidental water discharge only if the building wasn't vacant for 60 days before the loss. If you expect gaps between tenants, ask how vacancy is defined, how long you have and what changes after that.

### 9. Extras on the property

Pools, hot tubs, trampolines and some pets can raise the premium or require more liability coverage. If your rental has a pool or spa, our [pool and hot tub liability guide](https://getrentlane.com/blog/pool-hot-tub-liability-landlord) covers the extra steps.

## How to get an accurate landlord insurance quote

1. **Gather the details first.** Address, year built, square footage, roof age, recent updates (roof, electrical, plumbing, HVAC), any pool, the type of rental (long-term lease or short-term stays), when the lease starts, and any claims in the last several years.
2. **Call your current insurer.** Tell them you're turning the home into a rental and ask what they offer. They may also have a multi-policy discount if they insure your new home or car.
3. **Get at least two more quotes,** for example through an independent agent.
4. **Ask for the same coverage from everyone.** Same form (for example DP-3), same dwelling amount, same liability limit, same deductible, same loss-of-rents period.
5. **Read the declarations page, not just the price.** Confirm liability is included, how loss of rents works, and what the vacancy rules are.
6. **Get the new policy in writing before the lease starts**, so there's no gap between the old policy and the new one.

## Why you must tell your homeowners insurer when you start renting

Don't leave the old homeowners policy in place and hope. Triple-I's advice is that your first step before renting out your home should be to call your insurance agent. The NAIC adds that homeowners policies usually exclude or give limited coverage for business activity in the home, and that insurers may deny a claim on a rental even when the policy doesn't spell out a rental exclusion.

In plain terms: if there's a fire or a tenant's guest is hurt, and the insurer learns the house was rented under a policy priced for an owner living there, you could be left paying for the loss yourself.

If you have a mortgage, your loan documents almost certainly require you to keep the property insured, and your lender may need to see the new policy. Our [accidental landlord guide](https://getrentlane.com/blog/accidental-landlord-guide) covers the lender, insurer and tax calls to make, and [how to rent out your house](https://getrentlane.com/blog/how-to-rent-out-your-house) puts the insurance switch in order with everything else.

## Renters insurance for your tenants

Renters insurance is the tenant's policy, and the tenant pays for it, so it doesn't add to your costs. It covers their belongings and their own liability, which your policy doesn't.

In many states you can require renters insurance in the lease, but check your state and local rules first, and remember it doesn't replace your own policy. Our [renters insurance requirements guide](https://getrentlane.com/blog/renters-insurance-requirements-landlord-guide) covers what to ask for and how to check proof of coverage.

## Do you need an umbrella policy?

An umbrella policy adds a layer of liability coverage on top of your other policies. The [NAIC explains](https://content.naic.org/article/whats-umbrella-policy) that it can pay liability and legal defense costs above what your primary policy pays. Triple-I notes that insurers usually want you to carry a minimum amount of liability on your underlying policies (it cites about $300,000 on a homeowners policy and $250,000 on auto) before they'll sell you an umbrella.

For a landlord, two cost questions matter:

- **Does the umbrella cover rental property?** Ask directly, and ask whether there's a limit on the number of units.
- **What does raising your underlying limits cost?** The umbrella's price plus any increase to the liability limit on your landlord policy is the true cost.

If you have savings or other assets a lawsuit could reach, ask for an umbrella quote when you shop your landlord policy.

## Ways to lower the cost of landlord insurance

1. **Shop around every year or two.** The NAIC says premiums vary widely between companies. Re-quote at renewal, especially if your rate jumped.
2. **Raise the deductible to a level you could pay tomorrow.** Keep that amount in your [landlord emergency fund](https://getrentlane.com/blog/landlord-emergency-fund-setup) so a claim never becomes a crisis.
3. **Bundle.** Insuring the rental, your own home and your car with one company may earn a discount.
4. **Ask about discounts.** The NAIC lists examples like a new roof, storm shutters and home security devices, and names smoke detectors among the factors insurers consider.
5. **Fix known problems before you quote.** An old roof or outdated electrical panel can raise the price or limit your options.
6. **Insure the rebuild cost, not more or less.** Over-insuring wastes money. Under-insuring to save on premium can leave you short after a big loss.
7. **Save claims for real losses.** Paying for small repairs yourself helps keep your claims history clean.
8. **Keep vacancies short.** Fewer empty months means fewer run-ins with vacancy limits, and less time for an unnoticed leak to turn into a big claim.

One thing not to cut: liability. It protects everything else you own.

## Is landlord insurance tax-deductible?

Generally, yes, for a property you rent out. [IRS Publication 527](https://www.irs.gov/publications/p527) lists insurance among the most common rental expenses, and you report rental income and expenses on Schedule E. A few details from Pub 527 matter for insurance:

- **Prepaid premiums:** if you pay a premium for more than one year in advance, you can't deduct the whole amount in the year you pay it. You deduct only the part that applies to each year.
- **Timing:** if you use the cash method, which is common for individual landlords, you generally deduct rental expenses in the year you pay them.
- **Vacant periods:** while a property is held out for rent but sits empty, you may be able to deduct ordinary and necessary expenses for maintaining it. You can't deduct the rent you didn't get.
- **Personal use or renting part of a home:** if you rent a room or use the property yourself part of the year, Pub 527 explains how to divide expenses between rental and personal use.

Our [Schedule E filing guide](https://getrentlane.com/blog/landlord-tax-filing-schedule-e-guide) shows where insurance goes on the form, and [rental property tax deductions](https://getrentlane.com/blog/rental-property-tax-deductions-2026) covers the other expenses landlords often miss. Tax rules have exceptions, so check your situation with a tax professional.

## Put insurance in your rental budget

Insurance is a fixed cost you pay whether or not the rent comes in, so it belongs in your numbers before you set the rent. Once you have a real quote, divide the annual premium by 12 and add it to your monthly costs next to the mortgage, property tax, HOA dues, repairs and vacancy. Our guide to [creating a rental property budget](https://getrentlane.com/blog/create-rental-property-budget) walks through each line, and the [rental property ROI calculator](https://getrentlane.com/tools/roi-calculator) has an annual insurance field so you can see how a quote changes your return. If you're still working out what to charge, the [rent calculator](https://getrentlane.com/tools/rent-calculator) can help with the income side.

Keep the declarations page, renewal notices and proof of payment with your rental records for tax time and any future claim.

### Keep your insurance premiums with your rental records

Rentlane keeps expense records, including insurance premiums, next to each property's rent ledger, and exports a Schedule E CSV for you or your tax preparer. Your tenants keep paying you directly, the same way they do now.

[Download for iPhone →](https://apps.apple.com/app/id6763688888?pt=128818807&ct=blog&mt=8)

For every other step before your first tenant, use the [first-time landlord checklist](https://getrentlane.com/blog/first-time-landlord-checklist).

## FAQ

### How much is landlord insurance?

It depends on the house and where it is, so there's no reliable national figure. Triple-I says landlord policies generally cost about 25% more than a standard homeowners policy on the same property. Compare at least three quotes for the same coverage.

### Is landlord insurance more expensive than homeowners insurance?

Usually, yes. Triple-I says landlord policies generally cost about 25% more than a homeowners policy on the same property, to pay for protections like loss-of-rent coverage. Your own comparison can differ because a landlord policy usually doesn't insure your personal belongings.

### Do I need landlord insurance if I rent out my house?

In practice, yes. Homeowners policies are written for a home you live in and usually exclude or limit coverage for business use, so a claim on a rented house could be denied. Call your insurer before the lease starts and switch to a landlord (dwelling) policy or whatever coverage they confirm in writing.

### Is landlord insurance required by law?

Usually it's your mortgage lender, not a statute, that requires you to insure the property. Check your loan documents, HOA rules and local rental rules. Without coverage, you pay for any fire, storm damage or lawsuit yourself.

### Does homeowners insurance cover short-term rentals?

Often not. Triple-I says regular homeowners insurance typically doesn't cover losses from commercial activity, and owners planning short-term rentals need additional coverage. Tell your insurer before your first guest.

### Is landlord insurance tax-deductible?

Generally, yes, as a rental expense on Schedule E. IRS Publication 527 lists insurance among common rental expenses. If you prepay more than one year, you deduct only the part for each year. Ask a tax professional about your situation.

### Does landlord insurance cover my tenant's belongings?

No. A landlord policy covers the building and your interest in it, not the tenant's possessions. Tenants need their own renters insurance, which many landlords require in the lease where state law allows.

**Disclaimer:** Information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. Laws vary by state and locality. Consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Product pricing and features mentioned are accurate as of the publication date but may change.

---
Rentlane is an iPhone app for independent landlords (1–20 units) to track rent, leases, maintenance and expenses. Free to download; one month free for eligible new subscribers, then $8.99 a month through Apple. Download: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6763688888?pt=128818807&ct=md-blog&mt=8
